• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Kenny's Castaways: Authentic Italian Dining with Fresh Pasta & Classic Flavors in Montauk

Nestled in Montauk, Kenny’s Castaways offers a warm and inviting Italian dining experience defined by fresh, handcrafted dishes. Highlights like Mozzarella Napoleon, Grandma's Lasagna with rich Bolognese and Bechamel sauce, and indulgent desserts such as Tiramisu and Cannoli showcase authentic flavors elevated by skilled craftsmanship. Patrons praise the attentive service, with Mario and staff enhancing each visit through thoughtful recommendations. The menu’s balance of classic pasta, vibrant antipasto, and hearty mains like Chicken Parmigiana and Rack of Lamb reflects both tradition and creativity. Kenny’s Castaways is a culinary haven where genuine Italian warmth meets memorable taste.

Kenny's Castaways at a glance

  • Address 432 W Lake Dr Ground floor, Montauk, NY 11954, United States
  • Phone +1 631-668-5555
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Kenny's Castaways: Reviews & Ratings

Stephen O'Donnell
5

Great food & fantastic service. We tried four appetisers, main courses and dessert - all fantastic. Mario was great looking after us and advising us how much to order. Will come again

Ann-Marie Pearce
5

Great casual Italian meal. Fresh pasta, delicious appetizers.

Dante Skidmore
5

In town for 5 nights, and came here twice. Dinner was excellent both times. Below is my espresso encrusted yellow fin tuna. Try the zeppole for desert!!! Staff is attentive, friendly and always helpful.

David Laster
5

Had a great meal tonight on a cold rainy day. Chicken Parmesan and Spicy meat Pizza. Paired with an Aperol Spritz and Spicy Paloma. Excellent service by “Danny from Miami”

Evangeline Kohn
5

Best dining experience ever. Mario and staff amazing. The lasagna was delicious. The place is warm and inviting. The treatment we received was the mark of a true professional restaurant. Thank you Mario we will be back. Any negative reviews don't believe them. We recommended your place to 10 people back at our hotel.

Sharon Regali
5

I have no clue how this place has ever been rated less than a 5. Ask for Mario he is absolutely outstanding… their food is filled with flavor and authenticity…. I now don’t want to eat anywhere else. The atmosphere is warm and very comfortable. Making the perfect dinner spot for Sunday family dinners …

Grainne Ward
5

We ate at Kenny’s Castaways last. Night October 12th 2024 and it definitely surpassed even its best reviews! There was four of us and the appetizers were fresh and delicious, with an assortment of tuna tartare, beet salad, fresh mozzeralla and calamari! Our main courses consisted of grilled salmon, pasta, and pizza with various toppings! All the food was clean and fresh. Our waiter Mario was friendly and informative with an interesting personality which is sadly lacking in other restaurants. The overall ambience was cool, with background music that included some Van Morrison hits! I would have no hesitation recommending Kenny’s Castaway, great place to take friends and relatives!

Douglas Koch
5

One of the best meals I have ever had. Owner took the time to talk to us. Don’t listen to the 1 star reviews. It’s political sabotage. I had the veal Parmesan special with linguini. My wife had penne ala vodka. Drinks and wine was very reasonable compared to other places. A must go to place.

Location

  • Kenny's Castaways
    Kenny's Castaways
    432 W Lake Dr Ground floor, Montauk, NY 11954, United States Hotline: +1 631-668-5555

Nestled in the heart of Montauk, Kenny's Castaways offers a warm and inviting experience that feels like a true Italian escape. From the moment you step inside at 432 W Lake Dr, the scent of fresh herbs and simmering sauces sets the tone for a memorable meal. The menu is a celebration of authentic Italian flavors, showcasing fresh pasta dishes like Tagliatelle, Fettuccine Alfredo, and Linguine, each crafted with care and precision.

The Mozzarella Napoleon stands out as a delicate appetizer, layered with creamy burrata and ripe tomatoes—an elegant start that prepares the palate for what’s to come. The Risotto is perfectly al dente and richly flavored, while Grandma's Lasagna, with its blend of Bolognese and béchamel sauce, delivers comfort and depth in every bite. Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken Marsala bring classic flavors to life with tender, juicy meat and well-balanced sauces that speak to true Italian tradition.

Desserts like Tiramisu and Cannoli provide a sweet, satisfying close, their textures and flavors perfectly balanced—not overly sweet, yet deeply indulgent. The zeppole comes recommended for those wanting something lighter yet irresistible. Pair your meal with a house cocktail such as the Aperol Spritz or a Spicy Paloma to complement the dynamic flavors on your plate.

The service here elevates the entire experience. Attentive and knowledgeable staff like Mario and Danny are more than servers—they are guides who ensure you order just the right amount and enjoy every dish. This thoughtful service creates a warm, personal atmosphere that makes you feel like a welcomed guest rather than just a diner.

Kenny's Castaways is more than a restaurant; it’s a destination for anyone craving genuine Italian cuisine in a relaxed yet refined setting. Whether you’re savoring the shrimp Alfredo or indulging in the rack of lamb, every bite reflects passion, quality ingredients, and culinary expertise. For those visiting Montauk, this spot is a must-visit that promises a blend of tradition, flavor, and heartfelt hospitality.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards